Similarity Between Inside and Outside in Architecture A Comparative Study Between Mies Van der Roh& Robert Venturi Trends

AL-Dabbagh, Shaimaa; AL-Dabbagh, Dr. Asma

doi:10.33899/rengj.2019.163115

	Similarity Between Inside and Outside in Architecture A Comparative Study Between Mies Van der Roh& Robert Venturi Trends
Al-Rafidain Engineering Journal (AREJ)
Article 9, Volume 24, Issue 1, 2019, Pages 46-55 PDF (1.38 M)
Document Type: Research Paper
DOI: 10.33899/rengj.2019.163115
Authors
Shaimaa AL-Dabbagh^* ¹; Dr. Asma AL-Dabbagh²
¹Architecture Engineering Dept,University of Mosul , Mosul, Iraq
²Architecture Engineering Dept, University of Mosul , Mosul, Iraq
Abstract
The relationship between inside and outside is considered as the principal one in architecture as it is one of its most important relationships in architecture’s history. Human had tended, from the very creation of being, to withhold a part of the outside space in order to form a special inside space of the building. This is done through containment as in making the cave as a refuge or through designation as in setting a space by using vertical or horizontal elements. This process is called “inside and outside” which might be the leading generated term of building construction. Human firstly and the architect secondly aim at finding, unceasingly, a relationship between interior and exterior spaces. And, as they do so; they manipulate the outer mass, inner space and mutual boundaries in-between through shaping them in a way yielding a relationship between both interior and exterior spaces; thus, to find similarity or dissimilarity between the shapes of the outer mass and the inner mass of the interior space. The present study attempts to study the similarity characteristic by studying its contrast as a characteristic of the relationship between interior and exterior to determine the differences between the architects' trends (Mies and Venturi) regarding to the relation of inside and outside. this relationship will be having a big role in determining the patterns of buildings, their trends, and intellectual and spatial affiliations. In order to achieve the objectives of the research, in the practical side, three (3) single residential houses were chosen for each architect, and After applying difference variables to the selected sample, throughout the study a vision had been put into words expressed in that: the difference between inside and outside is what is known as the (In between), Which is the resultant of, basically, pro forma purposes, which are adapted to perform particular functions later as in Mies Architecture, or any strict functional purposes as in Venturi Architecture.
Keywords
Similarity; difference; inside and outside; comparison of three-dimensional entities

References
[1] Shahlaei, Alireza&Mohajeri, Marzieh, “In-Between Space, Dialectic of Inside and Outside in Architecture”, International Journal of Architecture and Urban Development, Vol.5, No.3, pp.73, 2015. [2] Arnheim, Rudolf, “The Dynamic of Architectural Form”, University of California press, U.S.A., pp.91-92, 1977. [3] Durmus, Serap, &Gur, SengulOymen, “Methodology of deconstruction in architectural education”, Procedia Social and Behavioral Sciences, Published by Elsevier Ltd, 15, pp.1592, 2011 [4] جعفر، أوس جواد، "الأبعاد الأدائیة فی العمارة"، رسالة ماجستیر، قسم هندسة العمارة، الجامعة التکنولوجیة، ص64،83، 2012. [5] العامری، شذى عباس، "التواصل فی عمارة الفضاء الرافدینی"، أطروحة دکتوراه، قسم الهندسة المعماریة، جامعة بغداد، ص35، 2010. [6] عمر، أحمد مختار، "معجم اللغة العربیة المعاصرة"، الطبعة الأولى، عالم الکتب، القاهرة، ص1161-1162-1163، 2008. [7] معلوف، لویس، "المنجد فی اللغة"، دار المشرق، بیروت، ص943، 1998. [8] سکوت، روبرت جیلام، "أسس التصمیم"، ترجمة محمد محمود یوسف و د. عبد الباقی إبراهیم، دار نهضة مصر للطباعة والنشر، ص33، 1980. [9] صالح، قاسم "الإبداع فی الفن"، دار الرشید للنشر، وزارة الثقافة والإعلام، بغداد، ص131، 1981 [10] Shriki, Atara, & David, Hamutal, “Similarity of Parabolas/ A Geometrical Perspective”, Learning and Teaching Mathematics, Volume 11, pp. 29, 2011 [11] Schulz, Christian Norberg, “Intentions in architecture”, Rome, pp.142, 1961. [12] المقرم، أسماء، "النظام فی العمارة الإسلامیة"، رسالة ماجستیر، قسم الهندسة المعماریة، الجامعة التکنولوجیة، بغداد، ص51-56، 1996. [13]الجمیل، علی حیدر، والتحافی، أصداء، "خاصیة التشابه فی مخططات المساکن التقلیدیة فی مدینة الموصل القدیمة"، مجلة هندسة الرافدین، المجلد 22، الإصدار 4، ص40، 2014 [14] Yeol Cha, Myung&Gero, John S, “Shape pattern recognition using a computable pattern representation”, Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands, pp.3, 1998. [15] ناصر، بتول قاسم، "القانون المطلق"، دار الفارابی، ط1، بیروت، لبنان، ص24، 2011.Google Books [16] Malnar, Joy &Vodvarka, Frank, "The Interior Dimension, A theoretical approach to enclosed space", Van nostrandreinhold, New York, pp.33, 1992. [17]شیرزاد، شیرین إحسان، "الحرکات المعماریة الحدیثة، الأسلوب العالمی فی العمارة"، المؤسسة العربیة للدراسات والنشر، الطبعة الأولى، بیروت، ص331-343-484-488-484-491-226، 1999. [18]فنتوری، روبرت، "التعقید والتناقض فی العمارة"، ترجمة سعاد عبد علی مهدی، دار الشؤون الثقافیة العامة، بغداد، ص222،173، 1987. [19]بانهام، رینر، "عصر أساطین العمارة، وجهة نظر خاصة فی العمارة الحدیثة"، ترجمة سعاد عبد علی مهدی، دار المأمون، بغداد، ص40، 1989 [20]جولدی، سینکلیر، "تذوق الفن المعماری"، ترجمة د. محمد بن حسین البراهیم، دار قابس للطباعة والنشر، الطبعة الأولى، بیروت، ص1، 2007. [21] عبد الجواد، محمد توفیق، "العمارة من الوظیفیة إلى التفکیکیة"، مکتبة الأنجلو المصریة، الطبعة الثانیة، القاهرة، ص157، 2016
Statistics Article View: 2,136 PDF Download: 803