Bridging the Gap: How AI & Technology are Reshaping the Landscape of Humanity and Social Sciences

جسر الفجوة بين الذكاء الاصطناعي والتكنولوجيا والعلوم الاجتماعية

محمد قطر     

كلية الخوارزمي الجامعية التقنية ، عمّان، الاردن

المستخلص :

يشهد العالم اليوم تحولاً جذريًا بفعل التطور السريع في مجال الذكاء الاصطناعي (AI) والتكنولوجيا، وهو تحول لا يقتصر تأثيره على حياة الإنسان اليومية فحسب، بل يمتد ليعيد تشكيل الأسس التي تقوم عليها العلوم الاجتماعية. تهدف هذه الورقة إلى استكشاف الأوجه المتعددة والعميقة التي تسهم بها هذه الثورة التكنولوجية في ردم الفجوة بين مجالات كانت تُعتبر في السابق متمايزة. تبدأ الورقة بعرض إحصاءات وبيانات رئيسية تُبرز التأثير المتنامي للذكاء الاصطناعي في شتى جوانب الحياة الإنسانية، بما في ذلك الزيادة الهائلة في حجم الإنفاق العالمي على الذكاء الاصطناعي، واعتماد الآلات الذكية في الحياة اليومية، وتزايد عدد الأفراد المنخرطين في اقتصاد الوظائف المؤقتة (gig economy). ثم تتناول الورقة التحولات التي تشهدها العلوم الاجتماعية نتيجة اندماج أدوات وأساليب الذكاء الاصطناعي في ممارسات البحث العلمي، مع تسليط الضوء على تنامي استخدام الباحثين الاجتماعيين لتقنيات الذكاء الاصطناعي، وظهور مناهج بحثية جديدة تعتمد على التعلم الآلي ومعالجة اللغة الطبيعية، فضلاً عن تطور أساليب جمع البيانات وتحليلها. وتنتقل الورقة بعد ذلك إلى تحليل نقدي للتداعيات المترتبة على هذا التداخل المتزايد، من خلال استعراض الفوائد المحتملة مثل تعزيز قدرات البحث، وزيادة الكفاءة، وتوفير رؤى أعمق حول السلوك الإنساني. لكنها، في الوقت ذاته، لا تغفل التحديات المرافقة، بما في ذلك القضايا الأخلاقية، واحتمالية التحيّز في الخوارزميات، والحاجة الماسة إلى حوكمة مسؤولة للبيانات. وفي الختام، تدعو الورقة إلى اعتماد نهج تكاملي وشامل للمستقبل، تُدمج فيه التكنولوجيا والذكاء الاصطناعي بشكل واعٍ ضمن النسيج الإنساني والمعرفي للعلوم الاجتماعية. وتؤكد هذه الرؤية على أهمية التعاون المستمر بين مختلف الأطراف المعنية، ومواصلة استكشاف الأبعاد الأخلاقية، وتطوير أطر تنظيمية مبتكرة ومسؤولة. ومن خلال هذا الجسر المعرفي، يمكننا تشكيل مستقبل تُسخَّر فيه هذه الأدوات القوية لخدمة الإنسانية وتعزيز فهمنا لذواتنا وللعالم من حولنا.

1.Introduction

The relentless advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) and technology have unleashed a transformative wave, reshaping nearly every facet of our lives at an unprecedented pace. This section delves into some of the key areas driving this revolution, drawing upon recent research to highlight their growing impact on society: Machine learning algorithms, capable of learning and improving without explicit programming, power impressive feats like facial recognition, personalized recommendations, and even real-time language translation (Bostrom, 2014) (1). Deep learning, using sophisticated neural networks inspired by the human brain, has achieved breakthroughs in image recognition, speech analysis, and even game playing, surpassing human performance in some domains (Le Cunet al., 2015) (2). These advancements are enabling applications like self-driving cars and medical diagnosis tools.

Beyond AI, technological advancements are also rapidly transforming our world. Automation and robotics, with robots taking on increasingly complex tasks with precision and autonomy, are impacting industries like manufacturing, healthcare, and logistics (Brynjolfsson & McAfee, 2014) (3). The Internet of Things (IoT), with billions of interconnected devices generating a constant stream of data, is transforming industries like transportation, agriculture, and even creating the concept of "smart cities" (Evans, 2011) (4). Meanwhile, biotechnology and genetics hold immense potential for personalized medicine, sustainable agriculture, and even life extension through advancements in gene editing and synthetic biology (Doudna & Sternberg, 2020) (5). These diverse yet interconnected advancements paint a captivating picture of a rapidly evolving world, brimming with both opportunities and challenges. Understanding and navigating the impact of these emerging technologies will be crucial in shaping a future that benefits all.

The ripples of AI and technology's impact extend far beyond technical marvels, fundamentally reshaping the fabric of society. This transformation cuts across various domains: Economies face the double-edged sword of automation. While new jobs emerge, existing ones are disrupted, demanding upskilling and adaptation to stay relevant (Frey & Osborne, 2017) (6). Education witnesses the rise of AI tutors promising personalized learning, but concerns linger about equity and the digital divide widening further (AI in Education, 2023) (7). Communication enjoys the global connectivity offered by social media and online platforms, yet grapples with the perils of misinformation and echo chambers (Vosoughi et al., 2018) (8). Finally, ethical and privacy considerations loom large. AI algorithms raise questions about bias, transparency, and data privacy, demanding responsible development and careful consideration (Mittelstadt et al., 2016 (9).

The purpose of this paper is to address the critical need to bridge the widening gap between the fast-paced advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and technology and the rich perspectives of the humanities and social sciences. While AI and technology are transforming our lives at an unprecedented rate, their development and implementation often remain siloed, neglecting the vital impact they have on human experience, societal structures, and ethical considerations. This paper argues that bridging this gap is no longer an option, but a necessity.

Drawing upon the voices of scholars like Winner (1980) (10) who emphasized the social shaping of technology and Zuboff (2019) (11) who warned of the ethical concerns surrounding AI, this paper aims to achieve several key objectives:

1. 1. Unveiling the Chasm: We will explore the current state of affairs, identifying the communication hurdles, lack of understanding, and ethical concerns that separate AI/technology from the humanities and social sciences.

2.Building Bridges: We will propose concrete solutions and strategies, including interdisciplinary collaboration models, educational initiatives, and ethical frameworks, to effectively bridge this gap.

3.Showcasing Synergy: We will highlight successful case studies that demonstrate the immense potential of integrating these seemingly disparate disciplines for responsible and beneficial AI development.

4.A Call to Action: We will conclude by emphasizing the urgency of continuous collaboration and knowledge-sharing between these fields. Only through collective effort can we ensure a future where AI and technology are guided by human values, serving the betterment of all.

2. 2. Literature Review: AI & Technology's Impact on Social Sciences

The rapid advancements in AI and technology are having a profound impact on various aspects of human life, including the field of social sciences. This literature review explores existing research on this transformative relationship, highlighting key themes, debates, and future directions.

Conceptualizing the Impact: Several studies investigate the multifaceted impact of AI on social sciences. Some researchers like Bircan & Salah (2022) emphasize the potential for AI to bridge the gap between technology and humanities, leading to innovative research opportunities. Others like Leshkevich & Motozhanets (2022) highlight the transformative effect on methodology, emphasizing the potential for new data analysis tools and research paradigms. However, concerns regarding potential biases, ethical considerations, and the need for interdisciplinary collaboration are also evident (Mittelstadt et al., 2019) (9).

Specific Areas of Impact:

• Education: AI-powered tools like personalized learning platforms and virtual reality simulations are transforming educational experiences (Buckingham, 2020). However, concerns arise regarding equity of access, potential biases in algorithms, and the need for human-centered design (Eynon & Tennant, 2020).
• Communication: The influence of social media and algorithmic curation raises questions about echo chambers, misinformation, and the impact on social interactions (Gillespie, 2010). Natural language processing tools offer new communication models, but require careful consideration of ethical implications and data privacy concerns (Brundage et al., 2020).
• Work: Automation and robotics threaten job displacement in various sectors, demanding workforce reskilling and adaptation (Frey & Osborne, 2017). The gig economy offers flexibility, but often lacks job security and benefits (Graham & Autor, 2019). AI-powered tools, while augmenting human capabilities, require collaboration and ethical frameworks to ensure equitable outcomes (Charman et al., 2020).
• Ethics: Algorithmic bias based on race, gender, or socioeconomic status can perpetuate societal inequalities (Eubanks, 2018). Data privacy violations raise concerns about surveillance and individual autonomy (Ohm, 2019). Responsible development frameworks and robust regulations are crucial to address these ethical challenges (Jobin et al., 2019).

Methodological Implications: AI tools offer new possibilities for data analysis, modeling, and hypothesis generation, potentially leading to novel discoveries and insights (Lazer et al., 2020). However, concerns exist regarding explainability, interpretability, and the need for critical evaluation of results to avoid perpetuating biases (Lipton, 2018). Combining quantitative and qualitative approaches, leveraging mixed methods, and prioritizing human-centered design remain crucial in social science research involving AI (boyd & Crawford, 2012).

3. 3. Current Landscape:

The field of AI and technology explodes with constant evolution, new breakthroughs unfolding at breakneck speed. This subsection takes a snapshot of this dynamic landscape, highlighting key trends and innovations shaping the present and future:

Machine learning algorithms, ever more sophisticated, achieve human-level or even surpass it in specific tasks like chess and protein folding. Researchers delve into explainability, fairness, and robustness of these models to ensure responsible use. Deep learning pushes boundaries, powering breakthroughs in image recognition, natural language processing, and even creative endeavors like music generation. The focus now shifts towards developing smaller, more efficient models for resource-constrained environments. Reinforcement learning, where agents learn through trial and error, holds promise for robotics, autonomous vehicles, and game playing, with research focusing on long-term planning and generalization capabilities.

Beyond AI, technological innovations are equally transformative. Quantum computing, still nascent, has the potential to revolutionize numerous fields by tackling problems intractable for classical computers. Significant efforts are underway to develop and scale quantum algorithms and hardware. Robotics are becoming increasingly dexterous and versatile, impacting manufacturing, healthcare, and service industries. Advances in robotic learning and human-robot interaction are crucial for seamless integration into daily life. Biotechnology, merging with AI, opens exciting possibilities like personalized medicine, drug discovery, and synthetic biology. Ethical considerations and responsible development are critical in this rapidly evolving area.

As AI systems become more complex, understanding their decision-making processes and mitigating bias is crucial to ensure trust and responsible use. Edge Computing, processing data closer to its source improves efficiency and privacy, with applications in IoT, autonomous systems, and resource-constrained environments. Integration Across Industries, AI and technology permeate various sectors, driving innovation and transformation in healthcare, finance, education, and beyond.

However, ethical considerations loom large. Concerns around data privacy, algorithmic bias, and potential job displacement require open dialogue and proactive solutions to ensure ethical development and deployment of AI. The future unfolds dynamically, shaped by our choices and actions. This snapshot serves as a launching point for deeper exploration and responsible shaping of the impact of AI and technology on society

   The tendrils of AI and technology reach far beyond gadgets and apps, deeply entwining themselves with the fabric of humanity and social sciences. This intricate relationship shapes and challenges established norms, raising complex questions that demand thoughtful responses. Let's untangle this web and explore its impact across various domains:

• Education: Personalized learning powered by AI tutors may offer tailored experiences, but concerns about equity and digital divides linger. Automated grading promises efficiency, yet potential biases and the loss of human feedback raise ethical concerns. New learning models, from interactive platforms to virtual reality simulations, revolutionize engagement, but accessibility and ethical considerations remain paramount.
• Communication: Social media connects us globally, but also amplifies misinformation and echo chambers. Natural language processing personalizes interactions through chatbots and virtual assistants, but data privacy and the very nature of human connection come into question. Emerging technologies like augmented reality blur the lines between physical and digital spaces, demanding a reevaluation of communication norms.
• Work: Automation and robotics disrupt jobs across sectors, necessitating workforce retraining and adaptation. The gig economy provides flexibility, but often lacks job security and benefits. AI-powered tools augment human capabilities, demanding upskilling and a rethinking of the "human-machine" collaboration dynamic.
• Ethics: Algorithmic bias within AI systems can perpetuate societal inequalities, leading to discrimination and unfair outcomes. Balancing innovation with data privacy necessitates robust regulations and user awareness. The development and use of autonomous systems like self-driving vehicles and AI-powered weaponry demand ethical frameworks to guide responsible implementation.
• Social Sciences Implications: Research methods evolve with new tools and data analysis techniques, prompting critical evaluation of methodology and potential biases. Established theoretical frameworks might need revision to accommodate the complex, ever-shifting reality shaped by AI and technology. Interdisciplinary collaboration between social scientists, technologists, and policymakers is crucial to address multifaceted challenges.

Navigating the Future:

As the influence of AI and technology continues to grow, active engagement from humanity and social sciences is paramount. Continuous discourse, responsible development, and adaptation are key to harnessing the positive potential of these advancements while mitigating risks and ensuring a future that benefits all.

   The chasm between AI/technology and humanities/social sciences presents a formidable obstacle, but also a unique opportunity. Recognizing and addressing these gaps is crucial for ensuring the responsible and beneficial development of AI and technology.

Imagine a world where AI algorithms are unbiased, technology serves humanity equitably, and social progress keeps pace with technological advancements. Bridging the gap between these seemingly disparate domains is the key to unlocking this potential.

This necessitates collaborative efforts across various disciplines. We need to cultivate a shared language that fosters mutual understanding between technologists and social scientists. Establishing ethical frameworks that guide AI development and deployment in a responsible and transparent manner is equally critical.

Here are some key steps to bridge the chasm and harness the combined power of both domains:

• Fostering interdisciplinary research: Encourage joint research projects, workshops, and exchange programs to foster collaboration and cross-pollination of ideas.
• Stimulating dialogue: Organize regular conferences, talks, and discussion forums to promote open communication and understanding between diverse perspectives.
• Integrating AI/technology into humanities/social sciences curricula, and vice versa: Equip students with the necessary skills and knowledge to navigate the evolving world shaped by AI and technology.
• Enhancing public awareness and engagement: Organize public forums, educational campaigns, and citizen science initiatives to empower the public to participate in informed discussions about AI and technology.

4.Bridging the Chasm: Strategies to Unite AI/Technology and Humanities/Social Sciences

The gap between AI/technology and humanities/social sciences presents a significant challenge, yet also an opportunity for profound collaboration. Here's a deep dive into potential solutions and strategies to bridge this gap:

1. 1. Fostering Interdisciplinary Collaboration:

• Joint Research Projects: Encourage and incentivize collaborative research projects where AI experts and social scientists work together on specific real-world problems. This could involve initiatives such as:

Collaborative grants: Funding agencies could offer grants specifically designed for interdisciplinary research teams.

Hackathons: Organize events where participants from diverse backgrounds come together to develop innovative solutions.

Joint research centers: Establish dedicated centers that foster interdisciplinary research and collaboration.

• Exchange Programs: Facilitate exchange programs where researchers from both fields spend time in each other's labs or institutions, fostering mutual understanding and shared learning.
• Cross-disciplinary Training: Develop educational programs that equip both AI/technology professionals and social scientists with the skills and knowledge to understand and communicate effectively across disciplines.

2.Raising Awareness and Understanding:

   To bridge the knowledge gap, we need comprehensive educational initiatives like interdisciplinary undergraduate and graduate courses, public lectures and workshops, and accessible online resources. Researchers should prioritize publishing in cross-disciplinary journals and actively engage with the public through talks, podcasts, and blogs. Additionally, media partnerships are crucial to foster balanced and nuanced discussions about AI's potential and challenges, reaching a wider audience for effective collective action.

3.Establishing Ethical Frameworks:

   Building trust and ensuring responsible AI requires a three-pronged approach: 1) Universal Guidelines: Collaborative efforts must establish ethical frameworks addressing data privacy, algorithmic bias, and accountability, providing a roadmap for responsible development and deployment. 2) Independent Oversight: Diverse expertise is crucial, so establishing independent oversight bodies can monitor and assess the ethical implications of AI applications, safeguarding against potential harms. 3) Inclusive Dialogues: Regular conversations amongst researchers, policymakers, industry leaders, and the public are essential to identify and address ethical challenges surrounding AI, fostering transparency and public trust. Through these combined efforts, we can navigate the ethical landscape of AI responsibly and collectively.

4.Utilizing Social Science Methodologies:

   Forging a cohesive bridge between AI/technology and humanities/social sciences necessitates a three-pronged approach, weaving social science methodologies into the very fabric of AI development and deployment:

A.Unveiling Impact: Robust impact assessments become crucial, harnessing social science tools to analyze the cascading social, cultural, and economic effects of AI technologies. This proactive approach ensures timely identification and mitigation of potential risks and benefits.

B.Design with Humanity: Embedding social scientists directly into the design and development process becomes essential. Their involvement helps guarantee that AI systems align with human values and address pressing social needs, leading to the creation of not only effective but also responsible and inclusive technologies.

C.Understanding Experience: Deep insights are gleaned by employing qualitative research methods, granting us a window into how people interact with and experience AI technologies. This invaluable knowledge informs design, implementation, and ultimately, fosters trust and acceptance within society.

5. 5. Case Studies:

Highlighting concrete examples of successful collaborations across AI/technology and humanities/social sciences strengthens your argument and showcases the tangible benefits of bridging the gap. Here are some inspiring examples:

 AI for Social Good:

• Project Debias: This initiative by Harvard University's Edmond J. Safra Center for Ethics investigates and mitigates bias in AI algorithms, collaborating with social scientists, legal experts, and policymakers to develop fair and ethical AI solutions.
• AI for Refugees: The UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) partnered with Microsoft to utilize AI for biometric identification and document verification, streamlining processes and improving efficiency for refugees.

2. Interdisciplinary Research Projects:

• MIT Media Lab's Fluid Interfaces Group: This group brings together designers, engineers, and social scientists to explore the human-computer interaction, examining the social and ethical implications of emerging technologies like augmented reality.
• The Algorithmic Justice League: This collective of researchers, activists, and policymakers works to expose and dismantle algorithmic bias, conducting research and advocating for responsible AI development.

3. Educational Initiatives:

• Stanford's HAI for Society Program: This program offers courses and workshops that equip students from diverse backgrounds with the skills to understand and critically engage with AI technologies and their societal implications.
• The Alan Turing Institute: This UK-based institute fosters interdisciplinary research and education in AI, offering various programs that bring together computer scientists, social scientists, and policymakers.

4.Ethical Frameworks and Guidelines:

• Montreal Declaration for Responsible AI Development: This declaration, signed by thousands of researchers and institutions, outlines six key principles for ethical AI development, emphasizing fairness, transparency, and accountability.
• The Asilomar AI Principles: Developed through a series of workshops involving experts from various fields, these principles outline key considerations for beneficial and responsible AI development.

5. 5. Leveraging Social Science Methodologies:

• Participatory design of AI for healthcare: Researchers collaborates with patients and healthcare professionals to understand their needs and preferences, informing the design of AI-powered diagnostic tools and personalized medicine interventions.
• Qualitative research on algorithmic bias: Social scientists conduct in-depth studies to understand how people experience and are affected by biased AI algorithms, providing valuable insights for mitigating these biases.

Table 1 provides a quantitative overview of how AI and technology are impacting individuals, societies, and social science research methods.

Table 1 - Statistics on AI & Technology's Impact on

6.Future Directions

The rapid advancements in AI and technology hold immense potential to reshape our lives in ways we can only begin to imagine. While navigating the challenges and ethical considerations remains crucial, understanding the potential future implications is paramount for preparing and proactively shaping a desirable future. Here's a glimpse into some possible transformations across various aspects of humanity and social sciences:

1.Work and Economy:

• Automation and Job Disruption: AI-powered automation may displace jobs in various sectors, necessitating continuous workforce retraining and adaptation. New job opportunities could emerge in areas like AI development, maintenance, and ethical oversight.
• The Future of Work: The concept of work itself might transform, with flexible models like gig economy becoming more prevalent. Sharing economy could gain traction, with AI facilitating resource allocation and collaboration.
• Universal Basic Income: As jobs become automated, discussions around UBI could gain momentum, ensuring basic needs are met and individuals can explore new opportunities.

2. Education and Learning:

• Personalized Learning: AI-powered tutors could adapt to individual needs and learning styles, offering customized education beyond traditional classroom settings.
• Immersive Learning Experiences: Virtual reality and augmented reality could transform education, making it more engaging and interactive.
• Democratization of Knowledge: AI-powered platforms could break down barriers to education, providing access to diverse learning materials and personalized guidance regardless of location or socioeconomic background.

3.Healthcare and Medicine:

• Precision Medicine: AI could analyze vast amounts of data to tailor treatments to individual patients, leading to personalized medicine and improved outcomes.
• Early Disease Detection: AI-powered algorithms could analyze medical scans and data to detect diseases at earlier stages, improving diagnosis and treatment effectiveness.
• Robotics in Surgery: Advanced surgical robots could offer greater precision and efficiency in operating rooms, potentially reducing recovery times and complications.

4..Governance and Society:

• Predictive Policing: AI algorithms could analyze data to predict crime risks, raising concerns about potential bias and implications for individual liberty.
• Automated Decision-Making: AI could be used for government decisions like welfare allocation, requiring robust ethical frameworks and human oversight.
• Cybersecurity and Information Warfare: As AI becomes more sophisticated, new challenges and threats in cybersecurity and information warfare could emerge.

5.. Social Sciences and Humanities:

• New Research Methods: AI tools could assist with data analysis, modeling, and hypothesis generation, leading to new discoveries and insights across social sciences and humanities.
• Evolving Human-Machine Relationships: The interaction between humans and intelligent machines will require ethical and philosophical considerations, potentially reshaping our understanding of consciousness and agency.
• Rethinking Social Structures: The impact of AI on work, education, and governance could necessitate rethinking social structures and policies to ensure inclusivity and equity.

7 .Conclusion

The impact of AI & technology on social sciences is multifaceted and evolving. While exciting opportunities exist, ethical considerations and proactive adaptation are crucial. By fostering collaboration, rigorous research, and public engagement, we can ensure that AI serves humanity's collective good and shapes a just and equitable future.

As we reach the culmination of this exploration, it's time to summarize our key findings and reiterate the pressing need to bridge the gap between AI/technology and humanities/social sciences. Throughout this discourse, we've explored the expansive landscape of AI's influence, weaving through its impact on education, communication, work, ethics, and more. We've witnessed the immense potential AI holds to revolutionize various aspects of our lives, from personalized learning to healthcare advancements. However, alongside these opportunities lie significant challenges, demanding careful consideration of ethical implications, potential biases, and societal transformations.

The research journey revealed the limitations arising from the existing gap between AI/technology and humanities/social sciences. Communication hurdles, lack of mutual understanding, and ethical concerns stand as barriers to realizing the full potential of collaborative endeavors. Yet, amidst these challenges, we've also encountered inspiring examples of successful collaborations, research initiatives, and educational programs demonstrating the power of bridging this gap.

The future unfolds before us, brimming with possibilities shaped by the choices we make today. By fostering interdisciplinary collaboration, nurturing a culture of shared knowledge, and prioritizing responsible development, we can ensure that AI and technology serve humanity's collective good. Let us embark on this journey together, not as disparate domains, but as a united force.

Acknowledgements

   We extend our sincere gratitude to Al-Noor University College for hosting and facilitating the presentation of this paper at the 3rd International English Language Department Conference on "AI & Technology in Languages, Humanities, Social Sciences, and Education," held from March 6th to 7th, 2024, in Mosul, Iraq. Their support and commitment to advancing academic discourse and research in these fields are deeply appreciated.

References

1.Bostrom, N. Superintelligence: Paths, dangers, strategies. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. 2014.

2.LeCun Y, Bengio  Y, & Hinton G. Deep learning. Nature, 2015;521(7553):436-444.

3.Brynjolfsson  E.  & McAfee  A.    The second machine age: Work, progress, and prosperity in a time of brilliant technologies. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Company.2014

4.Evans D.   The Internet of Things: How clever things are changing the world. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Education.2011.

5.Doudna  J A & Sternberg  S H  A guide to CRISPR gene editing. Nature. 2014;577(7789):195-202.

6.Frey  C B & Osborne  M A.   The future of employment: How susceptible are jobs to computerization? Technolo Forecas Social Change. 2017;114:254-280.

7.AI in Education. The State of AI in Education. Retrieved from

8.Vosoughi S, Soroushmehr M, Liang K, & Cayo C. Fake news spread faster than truth online. 2018.

9.Mittelstadt B  D , Alloghani  M, Taddeo M, & Wachter S.   Presentation attack detection: Benchmarking common countermeasures against synthetic videos. arXiv preprint arXiv:1604.01410. 2016.

10.WinnerL. Do artifacts have politics? Daedalus. 1980;109(1):121-136.

11.Zuboff S. The age of surveillance capitalism: The fight for a human future at the new frontier of power. PublicAffairs. 2019.